Dustin Poirier vs. Justin Gaethje II Betting Tips, Odds & Predictions (UFC 291, July 29)

UFC 291: Poirier vs. Gaethje 2 Betting Tips & Predictions

It’s rematch time in the UFC, with Dustin Poirier and Justin Gaethje headlining the main event of UFC 291. With a stacked card of mixed martial arts fights taking place in Salt Lake City, Utah, this Saturday night, the winner of this lightweight fight will not only have bragging rights but will hold the vacant UFC “BMF” belt also.

Key Details About the UFC 291 Main Event

When these two met five years ago, Justin Poirier walked away the victor. However, a lot can happen in half a decade at this level, and the two men that enter the Octagon this weekend will be very different fighters.

Will we see a more measured, cautious approach from Justin Gaethje? Whose fitness will last the longest? Is this going to be fought standing up, or will the mat play a big role?

We answer all these questions and more with our UFC 291 Poirier vs Gaethje II predictions based on the latest Poirier vs Gaethje 2 odds.

ℹ️ Event: UFC 291 Main Event, for Vacant UFC “BMF” Belt
🏟️ Venue: Vivint Arena, Salt Lake City, Utah, United States
🗓️ Date: July 29th, 2023
⏰ Time: From 6:30 PM EST

Head to Head: Poirier vs. Gaethje

These two fighters met in April 2018, with Dustin Poirier winning just 33 seconds into the fourth round through a flurry of vicious punches landed on Justin Gaethje. Since then, each fighter has gone 6-2-0 in the UFC, with both losing to Charles Oliveira and Khabib Nurmagomedov, making this rematch a tantalizing affair.

Poirier vs. Gaethje 2 Odds

Before diving into our UFC 291 Poirier vs. Gaethje predictions, let’s take a look at the bookies’ odds ahead of this clash. Here are the latest Poirier vs. Gaethje odds:

Dustin Poirier to win
Best odds:
1.73 (8/11)
4.1
100% up to $500 on 1st deposit and 50% up to $250 on 2nd deposit
T&Cs Apply
4.9
75% up to $750
T&Cs Apply
4.6
125% bonus on your first 3 deposits! (100% Sports + 25% Casino)
T&Cs Apply
Justin Gaethje to win
Best odds:
2.10 (11/10)
4.1
100% up to $500 on 1st deposit and 50% up to $250 on 2nd deposit
T&Cs Apply
4.9
75% up to $750
T&Cs Apply
4.6
125% bonus on your first 3 deposits! (100% Sports + 25% Casino)
T&Cs Apply

There’s little to separate these two in the online betting MMA, with Dustin Poirier having his nose ever so slightly in front of Justin Gaethje at 1.73 (8/11), compared to 2.10 (11/10).

Dustin Poirier Current Form in UFC

Dustin Poirier has been on an exceptional run in the UFC, with the exception of two third-round rear naked chokes. His losses to Oliveira and Nurmagomedov are the only blemishes on his record in the last seven years, with one coming in 2021 and the other in 2019. Outside of that, the American has been excellent, twice beating Connor McGregor, as well as Max Holloway and Dan Hooker.

Poirier Advantages Over Gaethje

Besides the psychological advantage of having won this fight five years ago, Poirier’s main strength compared to Gaethje is in the grapple. He has seven submissions to his name compared to Gaethje’s two and is an all-round more proficient fighter on the mat. Many would argue he’s also a better boxer.

Justin Gaethje Current Form in UFC

It’s a similar story for Gaethje – things have been going great, with the exception of his losses to Oliveira and Nurmagomedov. Admittedly, his losses were more recent, and his wins came over weaker opponents by less convincing margins as well.

Gaethje Advantages Over Poirier

Undoubtedly, the way Justin Gaethje wins this is through his knockout power. With 18 knockout wins to his name from 28 professional fights, Gaethje knows how to end a fight. He may not be the most skilled or adept, but if he catches Poirier flush with one of his bombs, it will be all over.

Dustin Poirier vs. Justin Gaethje 2 Betting Tips

Enough talk, let’s get to our UFC 291 Poirier vs Gaethje II predictions and most interesting options offered by Utah bookies. Whether you’re after high-odds UFC or just a little taster to get your feet wet this weekend, we have the Dustin Poirier vs Justin Gaethje tips for you.

Dustin Poirier to Win Outright @ 1.73 (8/11)

Main Prediction
Dustin Poirier to Win Outright
Best odds:
1.73 (8/11)
Agree with prediction?
(2 voted)

2 (100%)

0

This time five years ago, Dustin Poirier was good enough to negate the knockout threat of Justin Gaethje. Since then, Poirier has only got better. While Gaethje has also improved, it’s hard to see Poirier not doing the same on Saturday night that he did in their first bout. His ground game will dominate Gaethje if it gets to that, and he’s also got a handy boxing arsenal to draw on too. Expect a tough bout, but Poirier to get the win.

Fight to be Over 4.5 Rounds @ 2.35 (11/8)

Event Prediction
Fight to be Over 4.5 Rounds
Best odds:
2.35 (11/8)
Agree with prediction?
(1 voted)

0

(100%) 1

While their 2018 encounter ended in Gaethje getting knocked out, we believe there’s a strong chance of this fight going the distance. Gaethje has tempered his approach since then and doesn’t fight quite as recklessly, meaning he’ll be less likely to open himself up to opportunities for a knockout.

Poirier is as skilled a defender as ever and could well suck up time on the mat for large swaths of this fight. He’ll know that if it goes to the judges, he’s an excellent chance of winning, so he won’t be phased by that. Both men have great fitness, too, so it wouldn’t be a surprise if this goes to a decision – or at least deep into the fifth.

High-Odds Prediction for Poirier vs Gaethje II

Gaethje to Win by KO, TKO, DQ or Submission @ 3.25 (9/4)

Risky Bet
Gaethje to Win by KO, TKO, DQ or Submission
Best odds:
3.25 (9/4)
Agree with prediction?
(1 voted)

0

(100%) 1

There’s a clear path to victory for Gaethje, and that’s how he’s won the vast majority of his fights so far—landing a big bomb on the face of his opponent. We don’t think it’s the most likely outcome in this clash, but there’s no denying that there’s a healthy chance it will occur. For those who aren’t inclined to back Poirier, then this is the best bet to take, with a nice return and four options for its realization.

Best UFC 291 Betting Tips

Dustin Poirier to Win Outright
Best odds:
1.73 (8/11)
4.1
100% up to $500 on 1st deposit and 50% up to $250 on 2nd deposit
T&Cs Apply
4.9
75% up to $750
T&Cs Apply
4.6
125% bonus on your first 3 deposits! (100% Sports + 25% Casino)
T&Cs Apply
Fight to be Over 4.5 Rounds
Best odds:
2.35 (11/8)
4.1
100% up to $500 on 1st deposit and 50% up to $250 on 2nd deposit
T&Cs Apply
4.9
75% up to $750
T&Cs Apply
4.6
125% bonus on your first 3 deposits! (100% Sports + 25% Casino)
T&Cs Apply

There’s nothing quite like a UFC rematch, and that’s exactly what fans in Salt Lake City will be treated to at UFC 291 on Saturday night. It’ll be a ripper of a fight, but we say this one goes the distance, and Justin Poirier wins, claiming the UFC “BMF” belt in the process. Follow our MMA betting tips and come out richer after the fight ends.

User Avatar
Author
Betting Guru

Tim is our betting guru. Every gaming site needs one, and Tim’s our guy. He has plenty of experience in betting online and is quite successful at it. Tim’s favorite sports are hockey, baseball, and Esports. Tim believes the latter to be the future of betting.

Related articles

Crowning a New Middleweight King? Dricus Du Plessis vs Khamzat Chimaev Betting Odds and Predictions (UFC 319, August 17)

Chicago welcomes the UFC back to the United Center for the first time since 2019, with a middleweight showdown that fans have long awaited. Saturday night’s main event sees champion Dricus du Plessis defend his title for the second time this year against unbeaten challenger Khamzat Chimaev, whose rise began with a dominant debut on Fight Island. With both fighters bringing relentless pressure and fight-ending power, Du Plessis vs Chimaev odds will be at the center of attention on August 17.
Aug 15, 2025

Legends Fight for The Last Time! Max Holloway vs Dustin Poirier 3 Betting Odds & Fight Predictions (UFC 318, July 20)

UFC 318 promises fireworks as two of the sport’s most respected names step back into the octagon. Max Holloway and Dustin Poirier are set for their trilogy bout, a fight that brings years of history and rivalry full circle. With Poirier looking to close out his storied career and Holloway aiming to cement his legacy, fans can expect a battle worthy of their legendary status. Here’s what you need to know about Holloway vs Poirier 3 odds ahead of July 20.
Jul 18, 2025

Who Takes Makachev’s Place? Ilia Topuria vs Charles Oliveira Betting Odds & Predictions (UFC 317, June 29)

Las Vegas brings the heat once again for International Fight Week, with a loaded card topped by a high-stakes lightweight title bout. Ilia Topuria, undefeated and stepping up in weight, takes on former champion Charles Oliveira in a fight that could reshape the division. With the belt now vacant, and Islam Makachev also moving up, all eyes are on Topuria vs Oliveira odds as fans and bettors look to predict who will emerge as the next lightweight ruler.
Jun 27, 2025
Comments
(0)
No comment yet
No comment yet
ADD THE FIRST COMMENT
Get even more!
Subscribe for early access
to forecasts and exclusive analytics
that are available only to our readers.
Thank you
for subscribing
An email has been sent to your inbox. To complete your subscription, please confirm your email. If you don’t see it in a few minutes, check your spam folder.

We wish you success and only winning predictions!
Oops!
Something
went wrong
Try again later or check
your internet connection.
You are already
with us!
Keep an eye out for new predictions and promotions in your inbox, and if you don't see our emails, please check your spam folder.
footballer